Endless - Kazzak

[Declined] Esā - Balance Druid


[Declined] Esā - Balance Druid
« on: August 11, 2017, 04:46:50 AM »
Character name:

Esá - the twisting nether eu



Introduction - Let us get to know you! (Please include Gender, Age and Country)

Name : Harun
Age : 24
Gender : Male (eventho i sexually identify as an attack helicopter)
Location : Turkey; Istanbul
Occupation : Studying Economics&Finance

Please provide us with the following:
- Link to your armoury: https://worldofwarcraft.com/en-gb/character/twisting-nether/es%C3%A1
- Personal warcraft logs:
Druid : https://www.warcraftlogs.com/rankings/c ... metric=dps (please note that i got my single target bis 2 days ago)

Nh:Dh https://www.warcraftlogs.com/rankings/c ... artition=1

Nh:Pala (had to play healer for sometime due drama in guild)
https://www.warcraftlogs.com/rankings/c ... 43255/11/#

En:Dh https://www.warcraftlogs.com/rankings/c ... 015726/10/

- A screenshot of your UI: https://postimg.org/image/5wscdyga1/
- Connection info results: @Vacation at the moment using 24mb/s pulling 50-70ms normally at my local
- Do you have a working microphone?

Stats - Please explain your stats priority and explain why you are using these.

Simcraft ; its all about getting stats to a balance.

Talents - Please explain your talent choices for a single target fight or an add controlled fight. And why you choose these talents.

3xxx232 for st , 3xxx113 for oneth cleave , 3xxx212 for sota aoe

Resources - Please tell us sources you follow to keep up to date with your class:

Class discord, Warcraftlogs, Mmo-champion, Kelani,Fatboss,Asmond for some ptr news

Raiding history:

vanilla : bwl cleared
tbc : mid tk/scc progress > pvp
wotlk : Full clear + hardmodes 10/25
cata : casualy played cant even recall
mop : tier 14 ; 6/6h 3/6h 4/4n after that i was casual
wod : casual
Legion : 7/7m 7/10m 5/9m Tos

Guild history and reason for leaving them:

Square One - Leaving cause of never ending drama

Expectations - What do you expect from us and what can we expect from you:

Expecting a solid raid and a fun social environment, just leading
You can expect a raider you can depend on

Freetext - Anything else you wish to add? Your last chance to impress us!

Playing the game since release, i consider my self a experienced player, i also was the officer in my guild. As i stated im leaving them because i cant take this level of drama. Looking for a guild that i can call mine and spend rest of my days in wow.
« Last Edit: August 15, 2017, 07:55:52 PM by Naturage »

Re: Esā - Balance Druid
« Reply #1 on: August 12, 2017, 11:17:18 PM »
Hey fellow Moonkin!

first of all, thanks for applying with a one-sentence-answer to each question.
Apparently all your links to your warcraftlogs.com doesn't work so I did a bit research myself (at least considering your Druid, you didn't link names to your other characters even though I found them, but no clue about those classes tbh).

Telling from your logs, you have the following Legendaries:
ED, Boots, OI, LatC, Prydaz, SotA and recently got IFE
Still you're playing the bosses with a strange Legendary Combo sometimes, even though you would be able to actually pick a way better outcome on different bosses.

I think even though you've listed a lot of sources to get information from, you should have a more detailed look into them.  Especially considering your choice of trinkets and choice of legendaries in combination with fitting talents. Also I don't quite understand your handling of ED when you're using it. 

Also can you please explain me your opener? It seems to be different from time to time.
And why you sometimes have less than 90% (even found some with 50% and less) uptime on your dots? Also you should get a 4-p WA aswell, cause it seems you're not tracking it, surging 2 times on 2 sec Acceleration left and I'm not talking about movement or capped AP situations.

At one point you are right, simming your character is everything. But I still would like to have a proof that you're aware what are you simming for, what stat is giving you which advantage, why are you using them, what are they affecting etc. You should've explained this inbefore.

Considering your guild history is "Square One" the only guild you've ever been in? Cause you listed playing since Vanilla, are there any other mentionable guilds and on which characters are the proof for your experience? I'm not able to find any tracking about your raiding experience before 6.2 on any of your characters.

Other than that I'd like to mention another point that is probably more subjective. How are you even possible to see things happing around your character, having those WA's right under it? My first thought was maybe you didn't scroll your camera on max, but damn you gotta hate volcanic as an affix.

Anyways, those are my thoughts about this.

Have a nice day and i wish you a lot of Chicken Nuggets


Re: Esā - Balance Druid
« Reply #2 on: August 13, 2017, 12:55:09 PM »
Hello there,

Sorry for the sloppy application let me clarify your concerns;

About the legendary choice ; i believe i played with best possible combination on mythic encounters, its a fresh char just recently got all of my bis legendarys. but i cannot talk so confident if you inspected my heroic logs tho, hc is the ''fun time'' in my guild i surely did mistakes there or just forget to change legendarys before fights. (i have 2 other druids that i multi-box with if you saw that log try to unsee it  ;) )

Sorry for dead links hope this works;
DH-NH https://www.warcraftlogs.com/rankings/character/1015726/11/#partition=1
Hpala-NH(bad logs my 1st attept to play healer so guild could progress) https://www.warcraftlogs.com/rankings/character/23343255/11/
DH-ToV https://www.warcraftlogs.com/rankings/character/1015726/12/
DH-EN  https://www.warcraftlogs.com/rankings/character/1015726/10/

I think you would agree with me if i said ed is only good on paper, its nearly impossible to hold %100 uptime in practise. I am unable to explain my actions unless i know what situation im in at that said moment.

During 1st week of progress while i was new i used x2 ls opener (its against logic, rookie plays)

After that i opted to ; 3.4s precast x3 sw>dots> berserking,Incarn>x3 moons> x3 ss puts me on 3t4p buff so i can get maximum efficency

Now that i got ife and owl it would be like : anshe start > 3.4s precast x2 sw > new moon > dots > berskerking,incarn,owl> x2 moon > x2 ss > switch elune > rotation

https://postimg.org/image/8cu5rsycp/ ; i should have posted this with 1st pic of my ui, cancel aura macro for t4p is on shift+r (moons are on r), you can see my t4p wa on mid upper right, with -5 sec cross tooltip. if i did 2 ss on 2sec remaining thats simply my mistake, again if its hc im not even suprised

About stats; Mastery is simply flat dmg increase if you play right, Haste(no ed no caps, yay!) is ap regen (more casts more ap and more dmg), Crit is rng dmg increase doesnt trigger procs for balance. Cause we having +crit chanse(artifact talents) on some of our skills its value is low, Versa is just flat dmg increase and some survivability gains value is tied to other stats. In conclusion, i do know what my stats are for, anyone that can read tooltips does know this, felt self explanatory  ;D

my complete guild history;

Istanbul(A)-chromaggus-eu (vanilla-early tbc) Rogue Esadiablo
Valkyrie(A)-chromaggus-eu (tbc)- Rogue Esadiablo
The Dome(A)-chromaggus-eu (Wotlk-early cata, guild transfer to twisting nether horde @ cata release)-Rogue Esadiablo
İnner Rage(H)-The Twisting Nether-eu (mid cata-early mop)-Rogue Crudelitatis (Account2)
Unwise Elders(H)-Aerie Peak-eu (early mop-mid mop)- Mage Burņ (i name changed to esa or esadiablo sometime in this guild)(Account2)[Bulk of this guild transfered to Perfect Circle on Kazzak maybe you know them] found my application to them if you want to see i can provide
ARMA(H)-The Twisting Nether-eu (early wod)- Rogue Esadiablo
Currently : Square One(H)-The Twisting Nether-eu - DH>Pala>Druid

Im fine with my camera!i can see just fine, i generaly play with near flying vision *flaps*

Again im sorry for incomplete, sloppy application. Figured you already did a check-up on me before contacting me + i wasnt at confort of my home while writing it.


  • *
  • 130
  • The barking tree
Re: Esā - Balance Druid
« Reply #3 on: August 15, 2017, 07:51:44 PM »
Hey Esā!

Sadly, we decided not to offer you a trial at the moment - main reason being that we have recently got applications from other people who have as good (if not better) applications/logs/experience/etc, and also play classes we currently need more. Since we can't really trial everyone we'd potentially want to, we have to make our choice.

Best of luck in your guild search!